# 2021 Tesla Model Y Performance

- Price (advertised): $25,994
- Market price: $25,590
- Deal: Fair price, score 46/100, rank 5 of 10
- Condition: Used
- Mileage: 83,833 mi
- Model year: 2021
- Color: Deep Blue Metallic
- Drivetrain: All-wheel Drive
- VIN: 5YJYGDEF9MF202023
- Photos: 27
- Dealer: paulmillerbmw.com, Wayne, NJ
- Market: New York
- Data as of: 2026-11-17

## Why it ranks where it does

- Advertised at $25,994, $404 over its market price of $25,590.
- Market price is what a 2021 Tesla Model Y with 83,833 miles is advertised for around New York.
- 83,833 miles is above the 60,000 typical for its age.
- Ranked 5 of 10 comparable 2021 Tesla Model Y in New York, score 46 out of 100.

Price is the dealer's advertised price, before tax, title and registration. Confirm price and availability with the dealer.

## Safety and recalls

- NHTSA overall safety rating: 5 of 5
- Frontal crash: 5 of 5
- Side crash: 5 of 5
- Rollover: 5 of 5
- Recall campaigns issued for this model year: 23
- Owner complaints filed with NHTSA for this model year: 1101
- A recall campaign covers the model year, not this one car. Check this car's VIN: https://www.nhtsa.gov/recalls?vin=5YJYGDEF9MF202023

## Specs

- Transmission: Automatic
- Fuel: electric
- EPA range: 303 mi
- Stock number: V9583348B
- First listed: 2026-10-09

## Itemized price

- Market Price: $26,999
- Doc Fee: $995
- Paul Miller Price: $25,994
- Price history: 2026-10-09 n/a, 2026-10-10 $26,994, 2026-10-26 $26,394, 2026-11-02 $25,994

## Real alternatives nearby

- Costs less: [2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range](https://carfinity.ai/car/2023-tesla-model-y-long-range-161592cfa140/) at $22,174, 119,015 mi, cadillacofmanhattan.com
- Costs less: [2022 Tesla Model Y Long Range](https://carfinity.ai/car/2022-tesla-model-y-long-range-bf1639ad16b6/) at $23,386, 101,095 mi, axischryslerdodgejeep.com
- Costs less: [2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range](https://carfinity.ai/car/2023-tesla-model-y-long-range-f79ace23bfb0/) at $23,981, 126,321 mi, smythevolvocars.com
- A step up: [2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range](https://carfinity.ai/car/2023-tesla-model-y-long-range-c444bbeaf6d7/) at $28,075, 83,325 mi, mbofmassapequa.com
- A step up: [2022 Tesla Model Y Performance](https://carfinity.ai/car/2022-tesla-model-y-performance-d34e67ef3527/) at $26,989, 93,942 mi, dchbrunswicktoyota.com
- A step up: [2021 Tesla Model Y](https://carfinity.ai/car/2021-tesla-model-y-90346e5d6dab/) at $27,491, 63,628 mi, carz4us.com

- Page: https://carfinity.ai/car/2021-tesla-model-y-performance-030d6a05d059/
- See it on the dealer's site: https://carfinity.ai/go/030d6a05d059
- More like it: https://carfinity.ai/used/tesla-model-y/new-york-ny/
