2021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade2021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 22021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 32021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 42021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 52021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 62021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 72021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 82021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 92021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 102021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 112021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 122021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 132021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 142021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 152021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 162021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 172021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 182021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 192021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 202021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 212021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 222021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 232021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 242021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 252021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 262021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 272021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 282021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 292021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade, photo 30
1 / 30

2021 Toyota 4Runner Nightshade

VIN JTEJU5JR0M5891169 · Stock #P5891169

$39,409
$584/moFinance with $7,880 down, 72 months, 5.9% example APR, tax inPrice details

Est. out the door $43,237

Plus $999 dealer document fee. With 7% GA sales tax (est.). Title and registration extra.

#22 of 35 comparable cars around Atlanta. How it compares

Listed for saleFair pricePrice drop $590Listed 43 days ago

Gray

Gas

4.0L 6-Cylinder V-Shaped

5-Speed Automatic with Overdrive

4WD

SUV

85,072 miles

fivestarfordsm.com Dealer in Snellville, GA

How it compares

Against the 35 comparable 2021 Toyota 4Runner for sale around Atlanta.

$424 over marketMarket price $38,985
Fair price: #22 of 35Score 44/100
85,072 milesAbove the 60,000 typical for its age
Price down $590It was $39,999 on Nov 4
Ranking: 2021 Toyota 4Runner, used

See all 35 ranked

Compared with every comparable car Carfinity read on dealer websites in this market. How we rank

Before you decide

Real cars nearby that may suit you better.

Change one thing

The closest real car for sale nearby with that one thing different.

Year20215 others
TrimNightshade5 others
ColorGray5 others
Drivetrain4WD5 others

Specs

Transmission
5-Speed Automatic with Overdrive
Engine
4.0L 6-Cylinder V-Shaped
Drivetrain
4WD
Fuel
Gas
Body
SUV
Exterior
Gray

Safety and recalls

2021 Toyota 4Runner, from the US safety agency NHTSA.

Overall
★★★★☆
Frontal crash
★★★★☆
Side crash
★★★★★
Rollover
★★★☆☆
1 recall campaign issued for this model year
  • EQUIPMENT:OTHER:LABELS 2022-07-06

    Southeast Toyota Distributors, LLC (SET) is recalling certain 2020-2022 4Runner vehicles equipped with 20-inch Black Gunner Wheels. The load carrying capacity modification labels are incorrect. As such, these vehicles fail to comply with the requirements of Fe

    Remedy: SET will mail replacement labels to owners, free of charge. Owner notification letters are expected to be mailed September 4, 2022. Owners may contact SET's customer service at 954-429-2000. SET's num

A campaign covers the model year, not every car.

Is this exact car affected? NHTSA checks it by VIN and shows any recall that has not been repaired.

Check this car's recalls

Before you buy, ask the dealer to confirm in writing that every recall on this VIN is completed. A dealer cannot sell a new car with an open recall.

36 owner complaints filed with NHTSA
Steering
13
Suspension
10
Service Brakes
6
Wheels
4
Involving a crash
3
Involving a fire
1

Counts cover every 2021 4Runner on the road, so popular models have more.

Price details

Advertised price$39,409
Dealer document fee+$999
All-in before tax$40,408
Est. out the door, with 7% GA sales tax$43,237

Dropped $590; last change November 12, 2026. Listed 43 days ago. Title and registration are extra. Tax is an estimate and varies by county.

Price history Down $590 since Nov 4

fivestarfordsm.com

3800 U.S. 78, Snellville, GA 30039 This car on fivestarfordsm.com

More at fivestarfordsm.com

Great deal#1 of 1
2013 Chevrolet Camaro 1LT10,559 mi · Used · RWD · Silver$23,642est. $313/mo$9,766 under market (29.2%)BelowMarket $33,408Above
Driven 800 mi a year, below average13 years oldFew comparable cars: 1Snellville, GA
Est. out the door $25,297
See this car
Great deal#1 of 4
2014 Toyota Camry SE56,927 mi · Used · FWD · Green$15,994est. $211/mo$2,919 under market (15.4%)BelowMarket $18,913Above
Driven 4,600 mi a year, below average12 years oldSnellville, GA
Est. out the door $17,114
See this car
Great deal#1 of 9
2016 Ford F-150 XL50,271 mi · Used · RWD · White$16,499est. $218/mo$11,073 under market (40.2%)BelowMarket $27,572Above
Driven 4,800 mi a year, below averageSnellville, GA
Est. out the door $17,654
See this car
Great deal#1 of 58
2024 Subaru Outback Limited10,109 mi · Used · AWD · Ice Silver Metallic$29,988est. $396/mo$4,274 under market (12.5%)BelowMarket $34,262Above
Driven 4,000 mi a year, below averageOnly 2 years oldSnellville, GA
Est. out the door $32,087
See this car

You might also like

More Toyota 4Runner in Atlanta. See all

Great deal#1 of 35
2021 Toyota 4Runner Limited48,962 mi · Used · 4x2 · Barcelona Red$37,157est. $491/mo$5,882 under market (13.7%)BelowMarket $43,039Above
Driven 8,900 mi a year, below averageAtlanta, GA
Est. out the door $39,758
See this car
Great deal#2 of 35
2021 Toyota 4Runner Limited57,518 mi · Used · RWD · Nautical Blue Metallic$37,810est. $500/mo$5,125 under market (11.9%)BelowMarket $42,935Above
Driven 10,500 mi a year, about averageBuford, GA
Est. out the door $40,457
See this car
Great deal#1 of 14
2018 Toyota 4Runner Limited107,350 mi · Used · RWD · White$27,633est. $365/mo$4,163 under market (13.1%)BelowMarket $31,796Above
Driven 12,600 mi a year, about averageBuford, GA
Est. out the door $29,567
See this car
Great deal#1 of 52
2023 Toyota 4Runner SR5 Premium10,926 mi · Used · Magnetic Gray Metallic$42,477est. $562/mo$4,754 under market (10.1%)BelowMarket $47,231Above
Driven 3,100 mi a year, below averageOnly 3 years oldKennesaw, GA
Est. out the door $45,450
See this car

VIN JTEJU5JR0M5891169 · Stock P5891169. Price is the dealer's advertised price and excludes tax, title and registration. Payment estimates are on approved credit. Confirm price and availability with the dealer.

Estimate my payment

$584/mo72 months, 5.9% example APR, $7,880 down
Price with 7% GA sales tax and dealer fees
$43,237
Amount financed
$35,357

Estimate only, on approved credit. Title and registration are extra. Your rate depends on your credit and lender.

Price details

Advertised price$39,409
Dealer document fee+$999
All-in before tax$40,408
Est. out the door, with 7% GA sales tax$43,237

Dropped $590; last change November 12, 2026. Listed 43 days ago. Title and registration are extra. Tax is an estimate and varies by county.

Price and change history

Down $590 since Nov 4

Advertised at $39,409 today. Listed 43 days ago.

Nov 4$39,999Now$39,409-$590 (1.5%)Nov 12Nov 4Nov 13

Tap a point on the line for that day's price.

November 12, 2026
Down $590 (1.5%) $39,409
November 4, 2026
First price $39,999
November 3, 2026
Moved to this dealer
October 1, 2026
First listed for sale

The dealer's advertised price each time it changed, with other changes to the listing.