| Used Mercedes-Benz GLC | 13 | Used GLC in Indianapolis |
| Used BMW X5 | 12 | Used X5 in Indianapolis |
| Used BMW X3 | 10 | Used X3 in Indianapolis |
| Used BMW M3 | 10 | Used M3 in Indianapolis |
| Used Mercedes-Benz C-Class | 9 | Used C-Class in Indianapolis |
| Used Chevrolet Corvette | 9 | Used Corvette in Indianapolis |
| Used Mercedes-Benz EQE | 8 | Used EQE in Indianapolis |
| Used Land Rover Range Rover | 8 | Used Range Rover in Indianapolis |
| Used Jeep Wrangler | 7 | Used Wrangler in Indianapolis |
| Used BMW X1 | 6 | Used X1 in Indianapolis |
| Used Audi Q7 | 6 | Used Q7 in Indianapolis |
| Used Mercedes-Benz GLB | 6 | Used GLB in Indianapolis |
| Used Land Rover Range Rover Sport | 5 | Used Range Rover Sport in Indianapolis |
| Used BMW M4 | 5 | Used M4 in Indianapolis |
| Used Honda Odyssey | 5 | Used Odyssey in Indianapolis |
| Used Audi Q5 | 5 | Used Q5 in Indianapolis |
| Used Mercedes-Benz G-Class | 5 | Used G-Class in Indianapolis |
| Used Land Rover Range Rover Velar | 5 | Used Range Rover Velar in Indianapolis |
| Used Ford F-150 | 5 | Used F-150 in Indianapolis |
| Used Porsche Cayenne | 5 | Used Cayenne in Indianapolis |
| Used Dodge Durango | 5 | Used Durango in Indianapolis |
| Used Honda Civic | 5 | Used Civic in Indianapolis |
| Used Subaru WRX | 4 | Used WRX in Indianapolis |
| Used Hyundai Palisade | 4 | Used Palisade in Indianapolis |
| Used Mercedes-Benz E-Class | 4 | Used E-Class in Indianapolis |