Ranked against the New York market

Top-ranked deals here

Great deal#2 of 29
2019 Subaru Forester Base Alloy Wheel Package44,751 mi · Used · AWD · Jasper Green Metallic$18,470est. $244/mo$2,061 under market (10%)BelowMarket $20,531Above
Price drop $2,400Driven 6,000 mi a year, below averageListed 57 days5-star NHTSA safety rating3 recall campaigns for this model yearRye, NY
Est. out the door $19,209
See this car
Great deal#4 of 117
2024 Subaru Forester Premium Standard Model25,312 mi · Used · AWD · Magnetite Gray Metallic$25,648est. $339/mo$2,798 under market (9.8%)BelowMarket $28,446Above
Price drop $3,122Driven 10,100 mi a year, about averageOnly 2 years oldListed 57 days5-star NHTSA safety rating2 recall campaigns for this model yearRye, NY
Est. out the door $26,674
See this car
Good deal#13 of 152
2023 Subaru Forester Premium Standard Model15,686 mi · Used · AWD · Horizon Blue Pearl$26,467est. $350/mo$1,886 under market (6.7%)BelowMarket $28,353Above
Price drop $1,703Driven 4,500 mi a year, below averageOnly 3 years oldListed 57 days5-star NHTSA safety rating1 recall campaign for this model yearRye, NY
Est. out the door $27,526
See this car
Good deal#22 of 63
2025 Subaru Crosstrek4,902 mi · Used · AWD · Crystal White Pearl$27,168est. $359/mo$1,505 under market (5.2%)BelowMarket $28,673Above
Price drop $3,602Driven 3,300 mi a year, below averageOnly 1 year oldListed 50 days5-star NHTSA safety ratingNo recall campaigns for this model yearRye, NY
Est. out the door $28,255
See this car
Good deal#19 of 117
2024 Subaru Forester Premium BSD/Rcta + PRG29,521 mi · Used · AWD · Ice Silver Metallic$26,068est. $345/mo$1,827 under market (6.5%)BelowMarket $27,895Above
Price drop $2,102Driven 11,800 mi a year, about averageOnly 2 years oldListed 46 days5-star NHTSA safety rating2 recall campaigns for this model yearRye, NY
Est. out the door $27,111
See this car
Good deal#27 of 63
2025 Subaru Crosstrek5,235 mi · Used · AWD · Crystal Black Silica$27,668est. $366/mo$1,136 under market (3.9%)BelowMarket $28,804Above
Price drop $3,202Driven 3,500 mi a year, below averageOnly 1 year oldListed 50 days5-star NHTSA safety ratingNo recall campaigns for this model yearRye, NY
Est. out the door $28,775
See this car
Good deal#3 of 804
2026 Subaru Forester PremiumNew · AWD · Dark Mahogany PearlMSRP $37,164$33,995est. $449/mo$2,055 under market (5.7%)BelowMarket $36,050Above
Do-not-drive recall issued for this model yearThe 2027 is out: this is last year's model4 factory upgrades ($3,779 original MSRP)Listed 57 days5-star NHTSA safety rating4 recall campaigns for this model yearRye, NY
Est. out the door $35,355
See this car
Good deal#2 of 804
2026 Subaru Forester SportNew · AWD · Crystal Black SilicaMSRP $40,248$36,800est. $487/mo$2,241 under market (5.7%)BelowMarket $39,041Above
Do-not-drive recall issued for this model yearThe 2027 is out: this is last year's model6 factory upgrades ($4,143 original MSRP)Listed 57 days5-star NHTSA safety rating4 recall campaigns for this model yearRye, NY
Est. out the door $38,272
See this car
Good deal#2 of 69
2026 Subaru WRX BaseNew · AWD · Ceramic WhiteMSRP $34,624$32,774est. $433/mo$1,940 under market (5.6%)BelowMarket $34,714Above
5 factory upgrades ($2,129 original MSRP)Listed 57 days5-star NHTSA safety ratingNo recall campaigns for this model yearRye, NY
Est. out the door $34,085
See this car
Good deal#41 of 261
2024 Subaru Crosstrek Premium18,595 mi · Used · AWD · Magnetite Gray Metallic$25,168est. $333/mo$1,018 under market (3.9%)BelowMarket $26,186Above
Driven 7,400 mi a year, below averageOnly 2 years oldListed 52 days5-star NHTSA safety rating2 recall campaigns for this model yearRye, NY
Est. out the door $26,175
See this car
Fair price#12 of 27
2021 Subaru Forester Limited6,764 mi · Used · AWD · Ice Silver Metallic$26,168est. $346/mo$556 under market (2.1%)BelowMarket $26,724Above
Driven 1,200 mi a year, below averageJust listed5-star NHTSA safety ratingNo recall campaigns for this model yearRye, NY
Est. out the door $27,215
See this car
Good deal#18 of 804
2026 Subaru Forester Standard ModelNew · AWD · Crimson Red PearlMSRP $32,775$30,325est. $401/mo$1,467 under market (4.6%)BelowMarket $31,792Above
Do-not-drive recall issued for this model yearThe 2027 is out: this is last year's modelPrice drop $4506 factory upgrades ($2,780 original MSRP)Listed 43 days5-star NHTSA safety rating4 recall campaigns for this model yearRye, NY
Est. out the door $31,538
See this car

New inventory by model

ModelFor saleMarket
Subaru Forester42Forester in New York
Subaru Outback34Outback in New York
Subaru Forester Hybrid33Forester Hybrid in New York
Subaru Crosstrek30Crosstrek in New York
Subaru Impreza11Impreza in New York
Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid8Crosstrek Hybrid in New York
Subaru Ascent7Ascent in New York
Subaru Trailseeker1Trailseeker in New York
Subaru Uncharted1Uncharted in New York
Subaru WRX1WRX in New York
Counts of new cars on ryesubaru.com. Last read November 16, 2026.

Used inventory by model

ModelFor saleMarket
Used Subaru Forester16Used Forester in New York
Used Subaru Crosstrek9Used Crosstrek in New York
Used Subaru Legacy6Used Legacy in New York
Used Subaru Outback4Used Outback in New York
Used Subaru Impreza2Used Impreza in New York
Used Chevrolet Colorado1Used Colorado in New York
Used Subaru Ascent1Used Ascent in New York
Used Subaru WRX1Used WRX in New York
Used Toyota RAV41Used RAV4 in New York
Used cars on ryesubaru.com, most common models first. Last read November 16, 2026.

About this page

Compiled from Rye Subaru's public website. Prices, availability and offers are set by the dealer. How we rank · Report a correction

Claim this listing