| Used Subaru Forester | 52 | Used Forester in Youngstown |
| Used Subaru Outback | 32 | Used Outback in Youngstown |
| Used Subaru Crosstrek | 21 | Used Crosstrek in Youngstown |
| Used Subaru Ascent | 15 | Used Ascent in Youngstown |
| Used Subaru Impreza | 6 | Used Impreza in Youngstown |
| Used Subaru WRX | 5 | Used WRX in Youngstown |
| Used Chevrolet Silverado 1500 | 3 | Used Silverado 1500 in Youngstown |
| Used Subaru Legacy | 3 | Used Legacy in Youngstown |
| Used Chevrolet Equinox | 2 | Used Equinox in Youngstown |
| Used Ford F-150 | 2 | Used F-150 in Youngstown |
| Used Honda Pilot | 2 | Used Pilot in Youngstown |
| Used Hyundai Kona | 2 | Used Kona in Youngstown |
| Used Volkswagen Tiguan | 2 | Used Tiguan in Youngstown |
| Used Acura Integra | 1 | Used Integra in Youngstown |
| Used Buick Encore | 1 | Used Encore in Youngstown |
| Used Buick Encore GX | 1 | Used Encore GX in Youngstown |
| Used Chevrolet Malibu | 1 | Used Malibu in Youngstown |
| Used Chevrolet Trax | 1 | Used Trax in Youngstown |
| Used Ford Bronco Sport | 1 | Used Bronco Sport in Youngstown |
| Used Ford Edge | 1 | Used Edge in Youngstown |
| Used Ford Explorer | 1 | Used Explorer in Youngstown |
| Used GMC Terrain | 1 | Used Terrain in Youngstown |
| Used Honda Accord | 1 | Used Accord in Youngstown |
| Used Honda CR-V | 1 | Used CR-V in Youngstown |
| Used Honda Civic | 1 | Used Civic in Youngstown |