Used cars/Subaru Forester/Indianapolis

Used Subaru Forester in Indianapolis

90 used Subaru Forester are for sale at 26 dealers around Indianapolis. The median price is $22,711 at 65,974 mi.

Ranked among 86 used Subaru Forester

Best used Forester deals in Indianapolis

Search all 90
Great deal#1 of 12
2026 Subaru Forester AWD3,332 mi · Used · AWD · Daybreak Blue PearlOriginal MSRP $32,385$28,798est. $381/mo$4,630 under market (13.9%)BelowMarket $33,428Above
Do-not-drive recall issued for this model yearPrice drop $4,386Driven 3,300 mi a year, below averageCurrent model year4 factory upgrades ($940 original MSRP)Dealer fee $799Listed 46 daysMoved here from another dealer5-star NHTSA safety rating4 recall campaigns for this model yearTipton, IN
Est. out the door $30,814
See this car
Great deal#1 of 5
2016 Subaru Forester102,698 mi · Used · AWD · White$11,499est. $152/mo$2,480 under market (17.7%)BelowMarket $13,979Above
Driven 9,800 mi a year, below averageListed 11 days5-star NHTSA safety rating3 recall campaigns for this model yearWestfield, IN
Est. out the door $12,304
See this car
Great deal#2 of 5
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i124,375 mi · Used · AWD · Dark Gray Metallic$10,255est. $136/mo$2,654 under market (20.6%)BelowMarket $12,909Above
Driven 11,800 mi a year, about averageJust listedMoved here from another dealer24/32 mpg5-star NHTSA safety rating3 recall campaigns for this model yearIndianapolis, IN
Est. out the door $10,973
See this car
Great deal#1 of 10
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i116,500 mi · Used · AWD · Dark Gray Metallic$12,760est. $169/mo$1,919 under market (13.1%)BelowMarket $14,679Above
Driven 12,300 mi a year, about averageJust listedMoved here from another dealer26/32 mpg5-star NHTSA safety rating1 recall campaign for this model yearIndianapolis, IN
Est. out the door $13,653
See this car
Great deal#1 of 8
2019 Subaru Forester Base80,925 mi · Used · AWD · Ice Silver Metall$16,700est. $221/mo$2,433 under market (12.7%)BelowMarket $19,133Above
Price drop $300Driven 10,800 mi a year, about averageListed 51 daysMoved here from another dealer5-star NHTSA safety rating3 recall campaigns for this model yearPlainfield, IN
Est. out the door $17,869
See this car
Great deal#1 of 8
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium133,464 mi · Used · AWD · Dark Gray Metallic$11,961est. $158/mo$1,848 under market (13.4%)BelowMarket $13,809Above
Price drop $1,039Driven 15,700 mi a year, above averageListed 42 days5-star NHTSA safety rating3 recall campaigns for this model yearAvon, IN
Est. out the door $12,798
See this car
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium
Great deal#2 of 8
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium97,201 mi · Used · AWD · Crystal Black Silica$14,266est. $189/mo$2,012 under market (12.4%)BelowMarket $16,278Above
Driven 11,400 mi a year, about averageJust listed5-star NHTSA safety rating3 recall campaigns for this model yearOnly 1 photoIndianapolis, IN
Est. out the door $15,265
See this car
Great deal#2 of 8
2019 Subaru Forester107,031 mi · Used · AWD · Blue$14,999est. $198/mo$1,920 under market (11.3%)BelowMarket $16,919Above
Driven 14,300 mi a year, about averageListed 12 days5-star NHTSA safety rating3 recall campaigns for this model yearWestfield, IN
Est. out the door $16,049
See this car

Deals against the market

26% of the 86 ranked cars here are advertised under market.

How a used car is ranked

Market price comes from every used Subaru Forester in Indianapolis: what price does at each year of age and each mile, then adjusted for trim, color and certified status. The score adds mileage for the car's age and whether the listing has photos. How we rank.

Prices by model year

Model yearFor saleMedian priceMedian mileage
2026 Subaru Forester12$32,7983,727 mi
2025 Subaru Forester9$30,33527,913 mi
2024 Subaru Forester10$29,66830,567 mi
2023 Subaru Forester9$27,26135,959 mi
2022 Subaru Forester6$22,44375,744 mi
2021 Subaru Forester3Too few to state69,933 mi
2020 Subaru Forester6$20,99984,079 mi
2019 Subaru Forester8$18,89076,273 mi
2018 Subaru Forester8$13,258135,451 mi
2017 Subaru Forester10$13,875115,456 mi
2016 Subaru Forester5$11,760102,698 mi
Model years with at least 3 cars for sale. Advertised price is the dealer's own figure, before tax, title and registration. 15 of the 90 are certified pre-owned.

Quick answers

How many used Subaru Forester are for sale in Indianapolis?

90 used Subaru Forester, model years 2010 to 2026, are advertised by 26 dealers around Indianapolis, as of November 17, 2026. 15 are certified pre-owned.

What does a used Subaru Forester cost in Indianapolis?

The median advertised price for a used Subaru Forester in Indianapolis is $22,711, from 90 advertised prices ranging from $6,999 to $35,751. Median mileage is 65,974 mi. Prices are before tax, title and registration.

Where is the best deal on a used Subaru Forester in Indianapolis?

26% of the 86 ranked cars are advertised at least 3% under market.

Carfinity reads each dealer's public website. A car listed on more than one site is counted once. Hybrid, plug-in hybrid and electric versions are listed and ranked as their own models. Dealer sites in this summary were last read between November 15, 2026 and November 17, 2026.

Looking at a new one?

117 new Subaru Forester are for sale in Indianapolis.

New Forester in Indianapolis

Used Forester in other markets

Other used models in Indianapolis