Used cars/Tesla Model Y/Sarasota

Used Tesla Model Y in Sarasota

13 used Tesla Model Y are for sale at 6 dealers around Sarasota. The median price is $40,784 at 22,107 mi.

Ranked among 9 used Tesla Model Y

Best used Model Y deals in Sarasota

Search all 13
Great deal#1 of 5
2023 Tesla Model Y16,223 mi · Used · 4x2 · Midnight Silver$35,212est. $466/mo$5,169 under market (12.8%)BelowMarket $40,381Above
Electric · EPA range 279 to 330 miPrice drop $1,273Driven 4,600 mi a year, below averageOnly 3 years oldListed 54 days5-star NHTSA safety rating17 recall campaigns for this model yearSarasota, FL
Est. out the door $37,325
See this car
Great deal#2 of 5
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range55,886 mi · Used · AWD · White$34,361est. $454/mo$2,847 under market (7.7%)BelowMarket $37,208Above
Electric · EPA range 330 miDriven 16,000 mi a year, above averageOnly 3 years oldJust listed5-star NHTSA safety rating17 recall campaigns for this model yearSarasota, FL
Est. out the door $36,423
See this car
Good deal#3 of 5
2023 Tesla Model Y Performance24,820 mi · Used · AWD$37,447est. $495/mo$2,246 under market (5.7%)BelowMarket $39,693Above
Electric · EPA range 303 miPrice drop $1,697Driven 7,100 mi a year, below averageOnly 3 years oldListed 30 days115/106 MPGe5-star NHTSA safety rating17 recall campaigns for this model yearVenice, FL
Est. out the door $39,694
See this car
Good deal#1 of 4
2026 Tesla Model Y Premium22,107 mi · Used · RWD · Stealth Gray$46,630est. $616/mo$3,024 under market (6.1%)BelowMarket $49,654Above
Electric · EPA range 294 to 357 miPrice drop $123Driven 22,100 mi a year, above averageCurrent model yearListed 14 days5-star NHTSA safety rating8 recall campaigns for this model yearSarasota, FL
Est. out the door $49,428
See this car
Fair price#2 of 4
2026 Tesla Model Y13,019 mi · Used · AWD$50,381est. $666/moBelowMarket $50,381Above
Electric · EPA range 294 to 357 miDriven 13,000 mi a year, about averageCurrent model yearDealer fee $1,299Listed 18 days5-star NHTSA safety rating8 recall campaigns for this model yearBradenton, FL
Est. out the door $53,404
See this car
Fair price#3 of 4
2026 Tesla Model Y Long Range10,705 mi · Used · AWD · Stealth Gray$51,012est. $674/moBelowMarket $50,567Above
Electric · EPA range 327 to 357 miPrice drop $1,622Driven 10,700 mi a year, about averageCurrent model yearListed 14 days5-star NHTSA safety rating8 recall campaigns for this model yearSarasota, FL
Est. out the door $54,073
See this car
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range
Fair price#4 of 5
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range56,484 mi · Used · AWD · Red Multi-Coat$37,431est. $495/moBelowMarket $37,160Above
Electric · EPA range 330 miDriven 16,100 mi a year, above averageOnly 3 years oldDealer fee $1,195Just listed5-star NHTSA safety rating17 recall campaigns for this model yearOnly 1 photoBradenton, FL
Est. out the door $39,677
See this car
2023 Tesla Model Y Performance
Above market#5 of 5
2023 Tesla Model Y Performance60,712 mi · Used · AWD · Gray$38,433est. $508/moBelowMarket $36,822Above
Electric · EPA range 303 mi$1,611 over marketDriven 17,300 mi a year, above averageOnly 3 years oldDealer fee $1,195Just listed5-star NHTSA safety rating17 recall campaigns for this model yearOnly 1 photoBradenton, FL
Est. out the door $40,739
See this car

Deals against the market

44% of the 9 ranked cars here are advertised under market.

How a used car is ranked

Market price comes from every used Tesla Model Y in Sarasota: what price does at each year of age and each mile, then adjusted for trim, color and certified status. The score adds mileage for the car's age and whether the listing has photos. How we rank.

Prices by model year

Model yearFor saleMedian priceMedian mileage
2026 Tesla Model Y4Too few to state11,862 mi
2025 Tesla Model Y3Too few to state14,642 mi
2023 Tesla Model Y5$37,43155,886 mi
Model years with at least 3 cars for sale. Advertised price is the dealer's own figure, before tax, title and registration.

Quick answers

How many used Tesla Model Y are for sale in Sarasota?

13 used Tesla Model Y, model years 2023 to 2026, are advertised by 6 dealers around Sarasota, as of November 17, 2026.

What does a used Tesla Model Y cost in Sarasota?

The median advertised price for a used Tesla Model Y in Sarasota is $40,784, from 13 advertised prices ranging from $34,361 to $55,500. Median mileage is 22,107 mi. Prices are before tax, title and registration.

Where is the best deal on a used Tesla Model Y in Sarasota?

44% of the 9 ranked cars are advertised at least 3% under market.

Carfinity reads each dealer's public website. A car listed on more than one site is counted once. Hybrid, plug-in hybrid and electric versions are listed and ranked as their own models. Dealer sites in this summary were last read between November 15, 2026 and November 17, 2026.

Used Model Y in other markets

Other used models in Sarasota