Used cars/Tesla Model Y/New Haven

Used Tesla Model Y in New Haven

8 used Tesla Model Y are for sale at 7 dealers around New Haven. The median price is $38,361 at 26,728 mi.

Ranked among 4 used Tesla Model Y

Best used Model Y deals in New Haven

Search all 8
Good deal#1 of 4
2024 Tesla Model Y29,723 mi · Used · Gray$38,367est. $507/mo$1,377 under market (3.5%)BelowMarket $39,744Above
Electric · EPA range 260 to 320 miDriven 11,900 mi a year, about averageOnly 2 years oldListed 39 days5-star NHTSA safety rating5 recall campaigns for this model yearWatertown, CT
Est. out the door $40,803
See this car
Above market#2 of 4
2024 Tesla Model Y Performance21,526 mi · Used · Pearl White Multi-Coat$41,777est. $552/moBelowMarket $40,400Above
Electric · EPA range 279 mi$1,377 over marketDriven 8,600 mi a year, below averageOnly 2 years oldListed 21 days5-star NHTSA safety rating5 recall campaigns for this model yearSaint James, NY
Est. out the door $43,448
See this car
Above market#3 of 4
2024 Tesla Model Y Performance19,046 mi · Used · AWD · Stealth Grey$42,791est. $566/moBelowMarket $40,598Above
Electric · EPA range 279 mi$2,193 over marketDriven 7,600 mi a year, below averageOnly 2 years oldListed 43 days5-star NHTSA safety rating5 recall campaigns for this model yearSmithtown, NY
Est. out the door $44,503
See this car
2024 Tesla Model Y Performance
Fair price#4 of 4
2024 Tesla Model Y Performance59,994 mi · Used · AWD · Pearl White Multi-Coat$38,354est. $507/moBelowMarket $37,322Above
Electric · EPA range 279 miDriven 24,000 mi a year, above averageOnly 2 years oldListed 16 days5-star NHTSA safety rating5 recall campaigns for this model yearOnly 1 photoSouthampton, NY
Est. out the door $39,888
See this car
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range34,719 mi · Used · Deep Blue Metallic$34,391est. $455/mo
Electric · EPA range 330 miDriven 9,900 mi a year, below averageOnly 3 years oldListed 47 days5-star NHTSA safety rating17 recall campaigns for this model yearWatertown, CT
Est. out the door $36,575
See this car
2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range26,295 mi · Used · AWD · Pearl White Multi-Coat$38,053est. $503/mo
Electric · EPA range 330 miPrice drop $1,125Driven 7,500 mi a year, below averageOnly 3 years oldDealer fee $798Listed 42 days5-star NHTSA safety rating17 recall campaigns for this model yearBranford, CT
Est. out the door $40,469
See this car
2026 Tesla Model Y7,342 mi · Used · AWD · Pearl White Multi-Coat$54,435est. $720/mo
Electric · EPA range 294 to 357 miDriven 7,300 mi a year, below averageCurrent model yearDealer fee $56,025Listed 16 days5-star NHTSA safety rating8 recall campaigns for this model yearMilford, CT
Est. out the door $57,892
See this car

Deals against the market

25% of the 4 ranked cars here are advertised under market.

How a used car is ranked

Market price comes from every used Tesla Model Y in New Haven: what price does at each year of age and each mile, then adjusted for trim, color and certified status. The score adds mileage for the car's age and whether the listing has photos. How we rank.

Prices by model year

Model yearFor saleMedian priceMedian mileage
2024 Tesla Model Y4Too few to state25,625 mi
2023 Tesla Model Y3Too few to state27,161 mi
Model years with at least 3 cars for sale. Advertised price is the dealer's own figure, before tax, title and registration.

Quick answers

How many used Tesla Model Y are for sale in New Haven?

8 used Tesla Model Y, model years 2023 to 2026, are advertised by 7 dealers around New Haven, as of November 17, 2026.

What does a used Tesla Model Y cost in New Haven?

The median advertised price for a used Tesla Model Y in New Haven is $38,361, from 8 advertised prices ranging from $34,391 to $54,435. Median mileage is 26,728 mi. Prices are before tax, title and registration.

Where is the best deal on a used Tesla Model Y in New Haven?

25% of the 4 ranked cars are advertised at least 3% under market.

Carfinity reads each dealer's public website. A car listed on more than one site is counted once. Hybrid, plug-in hybrid and electric versions are listed and ranked as their own models. Dealer sites in this summary were last read between November 16, 2026 and November 17, 2026.

Used Model Y in other markets

Other used models in New Haven